gareth wrote:
I have stated my view that short antenna are poor radiatiors based
upon a number of physics and electromagnetics text books in
my possession.

Nope, you have made a bunch of arm waving claimed based on the lack
of understanding of the difference between feed systems and antennas
as well as impedance matching.

Some have chosen to disagree, and repeatedly so, but their
case is weakened because they produce no evidence and seem
to want to rely on aggressive and abusive remarks in order
to win the day. (I have no interest in winning the day, only in
knowing the truth, which for me at the moment is that short
antennae are poor radiators, and I have no need to resort to
abuse to state that viewpoint)

On the contrary you have been repeatedly shown the results of antenna
analysis programs as well as simple Ohms Law which show you just post
nonsense.

You have yet to respond to such with anything but arm waving and hang
wringing over "personal attacks".

snip remaining arm waving and babble



--
Jim Pennino