RadioBanter - View Single Post - 50 Ohms "Real Resistive" impedance a Misnomer?

July 28th 03, 02:29 PM

(Mark Keith) wrote in message . com...
(Art Unwin KB9MZ) wrote in message om...
Roy Lewallen wrote in message ...
One of the most serious and persistent problems you've had in
communicating your antenna ideas is your insistence on creating and
using your own unconventional definition of efficiency. As I've pointed
out before, and to no effect, is that the term has a universally
accepted definition with regard to antennas. As long as you continue to
make up your own definition, you'll increase your difficulty in
communicating your ideas. But it's a choice you've made.

Roy Lewallen, W7EL

Roy, the die was cast years ago when anything "new" was trashed
without a hearing.

Without a "hearing" would be an apt description. I keep telling you
you should build one to actually see if it works, but you don't or
won't listen.

I now accept that all is now known about antennas
except the really deep things that Cecil is so bravely pushing on with
where I failed.

When it comes to the definition of "efficiency" yes, it is already
known.

Even if I was to demonstrate succesfully a different antenna I would
have as much success in persuasion as the U.S. Government is having at
home and abroad.

Why? Are you admitting it probably doesn't work?

Just forget about my antenna and go with the common consensus that it
can't possibly be true since I have no credability.

I don't think your antenna will work as you have planned, but your
credibility or lack of it, has nothing to do with it. I modeled the
thing. I know how it will work. Or at least the version I tested. MK

Mark,
Put the whole antenna idea aside The thing could not possibly work, my
activity is a total illusion. If anything new comes along, which is
highly unlikely since all is known,do you really believe it would be
the likes of me to find it? A guy who never went to college, can't
type or spell and has no credability. No Mike I am just an ordinary
disciple of the gurus on the net
sucking up every thing that they say knowing if I differ with them I
am not in conformance and thus not a part of the team.
Back to the real interesting part of radio, SWR, tuners, how far apart
should my antennas be,can I make a G5RV antenna with wet string and
away from antennas that are just a joke and back to reality and total
conformity.
I expect to obtain more friends now and continue with my happy life.
Your friend
Art