On Tue, 31 Oct 2006 19:06:34 -0500, "Jimmie D"
wrote:

I agree, unless you do a lot of connectors soldering is the best way to go.
It doesnt take long at all to get proficent at making good soldered on
connections. Crimp on connections can look good but be awful. A few years a
go a guy installed some equipment at work that had over 30 BNC connections.
He got an award for the installation and I got 50 hrs of overtime for going
back and really making it work right. Most of the work was repairing the
crimp on BNC connectors.. The problem with the connections, he used a crimp
tool that was about worn out.

Thank you for the response, however, because others have suggested
soldering I feel an explanation may be in order.

I have been installing soldered coax connectors for more than fifty
years and feel I was pretty good at it, however, with advancing years
I have lost considerable motor skills and can not hold a soldering
iron (or anything else) very steady. My problem, at the moment, is
trying to make up some BNC connectors using RG-174. Although crimp on
connecters may not be the best choice, for me they appear to be a
viable option. Hence my inquiry as to what would be a good choice in
crimp on tools.

73,
Danny, K6MHE

Danny Richardson wrote:

Thank you for the response, however, because others have suggested
soldering I feel an explanation may be in order.

I have been installing soldered coax connectors for more than fifty
years and feel I was pretty good at it, however, with advancing years
I have lost considerable motor skills and can not hold a soldering
iron (or anything else) very steady. My problem, at the moment, is
trying to make up some BNC connectors using RG-174. Although crimp on
connecters may not be the best choice, for me they appear to be a
viable option. Hence my inquiry as to what would be a good choice in
crimp on tools.

That's definitely a good reason, and the kind I appreciate more and more
as time goes by. I'm sure it won't be long before I'm in the same boat,
so I'll pay attention to the tool suggestions too.

Roy Lewallen, W7EL

Hi All:
My recommendation is to use the tool made by the company that makes your
connector. They know what works best with their connectors. Having said
that, all BNC's for RG174 and RG58 are almost the same and the inexpensive
tool made by Amphonal and others work very well. It will cost you from $50
to $70 but it will work OK. They take interchangeable dies and you can use
the dies from almost any similar looking tool in any of the handles. Type
N's for RG-213 work well in crimp and I've think that Amphonal's RFX series
crimp on PL259 (available for 213 and 58 with crimp braid and solder center
conductor) works well and a tool with interchangeable dies makes going all
crimp a little cheaper.
About 20 years ago I quit using as much as possible solder on connectors. I
find a well assembled crimp better in all respects than an average solder on
connector. I've used a lot of them too. I've worked for years in the High
Energy Physics world and have installed 1000's of connectors on coax. As an
example one small experiment we did had 9 miles of RG-213 with crimp on
connectors and 1 miles of RG174 cut into 2' pieces with connectors crimped
on. Not one failure do to connectors in the 4 years the experiment ran. The
secret is to follow the manufactures directions EXACTLY and take care not to
nick the braid or center conductor when striping the coax.

John Passaneau
Penn State University
University Park Pa.
"Roy Lewallen" wrote in message
...
Danny Richardson wrote:

Thank you for the response, however, because others have suggested
soldering I feel an explanation may be in order. I have been installing
soldered coax connectors for more than fifty
years and feel I was pretty good at it, however, with advancing years
I have lost considerable motor skills and can not hold a soldering
iron (or anything else) very steady. My problem, at the moment, is
trying to make up some BNC connectors using RG-174. Although crimp on
connecters may not be the best choice, for me they appear to be a
viable option. Hence my inquiry as to what would be a good choice in
crimp on tools.

That's definitely a good reason, and the kind I appreciate more and more
as time goes by. I'm sure it won't be long before I'm in the same boat, so
I'll pay attention to the tool suggestions too.

Roy Lewallen, W7EL

Hail Eris! On Tue, 31 Oct 2006 16:31:41 -0800, I PUNCE jabbered inanely:
Slow Code wrote:
Dave wrote:

Solder??

I know how you feel. I felt the same way after hearing there would be
5wpm Extras.

Danny Richardson wrote:

Looking for suggestions for a good crimp tool for installing coax
connectors. It will primarily for BNC connectors on RG-174, 58 and 59
cables. Although the RG-8 cable family capability would be nice too.

I do wish to avoid being a captive customer in that brand X crimp
tool only works well with brand X connectors.

And, of course, looking for the best bank for the buck.

Thanks,

Danny

wait till hf is filled with marqueer extras

That sounds exciting! Your foam should rise high, then.

--
Shon'ai COOSN-029-06-71069
"I was told there would be cookies."
Cross-Poasters For Goddess!
Remember: Straight people can't help it!
A petition to make the Five-Fingered Hand of Eris
the official symbol for the planet Eris:
http://www.petitiononline.com/ffhoeris/

"If you don't have pedicures AT LEAST every two weeks, don't talk to me.
If you don't floss every night and morning and brush at least twice a
day, don't talk to me. If you don't spend money on you hair and get
great cuts and color, don't talk to me. If you are heavy, don't talk to
me. If you don't shower every morning and take a nice bubble bath every
night, don't talk to me. If you don't have a loved one in your arms,
don't talk to me. If you don't keep an immaculate house, don't talk to
me. If you don't work, don't talk to me." -- Clearly, Martha Vandella
never wants to talk to me, which is for the best, really.
MID: . com