Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I understand that HP has used three different
OCXOs, E1938A, HP-10811, and the HP-10544. I haven't found any info on the first one. Leland- My HP counter has a variation of the 10811 oscillator. To calibrate it, I bought a 10 MHz rubidium-controlled oscillator on E-Bay, and it is impressive how little drift the 10811 has over a long period of time. I use an oscilloscope to compare the two 10 MHz signals, and can count the number of seconds required for the sine wave to drift one division, where ten divisions equal one cycle. I also bought the counter on E-Bay. The seller insisted it had been checked out and worked fine. What I found was that the 10 MHz oscillator could not be adjusted onto frequency, and it never quite stopped drifting. After an investigation that included purchasing a 10811A/B manual, I found that the 10811 had an open thermal fuse. Further, the HP/Agilent parts department was not able to determine the correct replacement part until I had the manual in hand, and could tell them the original part number! It seems that the 10811 (and possibly the 10544) oscillator series was originally designed with too low a temperature rating on the thermal fuse. At some point a new higher value was chosen. If you happen to encounter the problem, there is a good chance that if it doesn't have a burned smell, all it needs is the new part. Mine has been working flawlessly for over a year now with the newer thermal fuse. 73, Fred, K4DII |
#2
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
I understand that HP has used three different
OCXOs, E1938A, HP-10811, and the HP-10544. I haven't found any info on the first one. Leland- My HP counter has a variation of the 10811 oscillator. To calibrate it, I bought a 10 MHz rubidium-controlled oscillator on E-Bay, and it is impressive how little drift the 10811 has over a long period of time. I use an oscilloscope to compare the two 10 MHz signals, and can count the number of seconds required for the sine wave to drift one division, where ten divisions equal one cycle. I also bought the counter on E-Bay. The seller insisted it had been checked out and worked fine. What I found was that the 10 MHz oscillator could not be adjusted onto frequency, and it never quite stopped drifting. After an investigation that included purchasing a 10811A/B manual, I found that the 10811 had an open thermal fuse. Further, the HP/Agilent parts department was not able to determine the correct replacement part until I had the manual in hand, and could tell them the original part number! It seems that the 10811 (and possibly the 10544) oscillator series was originally designed with too low a temperature rating on the thermal fuse. At some point a new higher value was chosen. If you happen to encounter the problem, there is a good chance that if it doesn't have a burned smell, all it needs is the new part. Mine has been working flawlessly for over a year now with the newer thermal fuse. 73, Fred, K4DII |
#3
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Fred McKenzie" wrote in message . ... I understand that HP has used three different OCXOs, E1938A, HP-10811, and the HP-10544. I haven't found any info on the first one. Leland- My HP counter has a variation of the 10811 oscillator. To calibrate it, I bought a 10 MHz rubidium-controlled oscillator on E-Bay, What did that cost you? Also how long are the lamps good for anyway? I imagine they are expensive to replace. and it is impressive how little drift the 10811 has over a long period of time. I use an oscilloscope to compare the two 10 MHz signals, and can count the number of seconds required for the sine wave to drift one division, where ten divisions equal one cycle. I also bought the counter on E-Bay. The seller insisted it had been checked out and worked fine. What I found was that the 10 MHz oscillator could not be adjusted onto frequency, and it never quite stopped drifting. After an investigation that included purchasing a 10811A/B manual, I found that the 10811 had an open thermal fuse. Further, the HP/Agilent parts department was not able to determine the correct replacement part until I had the manual in hand, and could tell them the original part number! It seems that the 10811 (and possibly the 10544) oscillator series was originally designed with too low a temperature rating on the thermal fuse. At some point a new higher value was chosen. If you happen to encounter the problem, there is a good chance that if it doesn't have a burned smell, all it needs is the new part. Mine has been working flawlessly for over a year now with the newer thermal fuse. I assume if the thermal fuse is shot the oscillator won't draw any oven current? I did find a page that shows how to disassemble the 10811. It doesn't look all that inviting. Seems the author of that page had most of his problems dealing with the sticky tape they use internally. He had by the way also reported a drifting problem. That's why he took it apart. But he did say he couldn't find anything wrong with the unit either. Thanks for the heads up about a known problem with the 10811. -- Leland C. Scott KC8LDO Saw this on a Tee-shirt: "I am a bomb technician if you see me running try to keep up " |
#4
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Fred McKenzie" wrote in message . ... I understand that HP has used three different OCXOs, E1938A, HP-10811, and the HP-10544. I haven't found any info on the first one. Leland- My HP counter has a variation of the 10811 oscillator. To calibrate it, I bought a 10 MHz rubidium-controlled oscillator on E-Bay, What did that cost you? Also how long are the lamps good for anyway? I imagine they are expensive to replace. and it is impressive how little drift the 10811 has over a long period of time. I use an oscilloscope to compare the two 10 MHz signals, and can count the number of seconds required for the sine wave to drift one division, where ten divisions equal one cycle. I also bought the counter on E-Bay. The seller insisted it had been checked out and worked fine. What I found was that the 10 MHz oscillator could not be adjusted onto frequency, and it never quite stopped drifting. After an investigation that included purchasing a 10811A/B manual, I found that the 10811 had an open thermal fuse. Further, the HP/Agilent parts department was not able to determine the correct replacement part until I had the manual in hand, and could tell them the original part number! It seems that the 10811 (and possibly the 10544) oscillator series was originally designed with too low a temperature rating on the thermal fuse. At some point a new higher value was chosen. If you happen to encounter the problem, there is a good chance that if it doesn't have a burned smell, all it needs is the new part. Mine has been working flawlessly for over a year now with the newer thermal fuse. I assume if the thermal fuse is shot the oscillator won't draw any oven current? I did find a page that shows how to disassemble the 10811. It doesn't look all that inviting. Seems the author of that page had most of his problems dealing with the sticky tape they use internally. He had by the way also reported a drifting problem. That's why he took it apart. But he did say he couldn't find anything wrong with the unit either. Thanks for the heads up about a known problem with the 10811. -- Leland C. Scott KC8LDO Saw this on a Tee-shirt: "I am a bomb technician if you see me running try to keep up " |
#5
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
My HP counter has a variation of the 10811
oscillator. To calibrate it, I bought a 10 MHz rubidium-controlled oscillator on E-Bay, What did that cost you? Also how long are the lamps good for anyway? I imagine they are expensive to replace. Leland- I paid $225 plus shipping for the used rubidium-controlled oscillator. I had to build a 24 volt DC power supply for it. I have read various articles about lamp life. It seems that E-Bay sellers will claim that they were designed for several years of continuous use. The trouble is that you don't know how many years a second hand unit has already been used! They are most likely being sold after having been replaced as preventive maintenance. I only run mine when I need it for calibrating an oscillator. I would expect it to be cheaper to buy another used rubidium oscillator than to repair the one I have. If it does go bad, I will look into one of the HP GPS-synchronized oscillators that are available on E-Bay. I assume if the thermal fuse is shot the oscillator won't draw any oven current? I did find a page that shows how to disassemble the 10811. It doesn't look all that inviting. Seems the author of that page had most of his problems dealing with the sticky tape they use internally. He had by the way also reported a drifting problem. That's why he took it apart. But he did say he couldn't find anything wrong with the unit either. The oven won't draw current but the oscillator will. An Ohm meter check between the oven power lead and ground should be relatively low, maybe a few hundred Ohms? You DO NOT want to disassemble the oven! All you need to do is remove the end plate. As I recall, there is a flexible cable near the card-edge connector, that hides the thermal fuse. The original thermal fuse looked like a tiny electrolytic capacitor, and plugged into tiny pin-sockets on a circuit board. The new version looks more like a ceramic quarter or half watt resistor. If you are interested, I wrote up my experience and E-Mailed it to ARRL's Hints and Kinks. It was published on Page 68 of the November, 2002, issue of QST. Please do not take this as a condemnation of the 10811 oscillator. I am very impressed with how stable it has been over a long period of time. 73, Fred, K4DII |
#6
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
My HP counter has a variation of the 10811
oscillator. To calibrate it, I bought a 10 MHz rubidium-controlled oscillator on E-Bay, What did that cost you? Also how long are the lamps good for anyway? I imagine they are expensive to replace. Leland- I paid $225 plus shipping for the used rubidium-controlled oscillator. I had to build a 24 volt DC power supply for it. I have read various articles about lamp life. It seems that E-Bay sellers will claim that they were designed for several years of continuous use. The trouble is that you don't know how many years a second hand unit has already been used! They are most likely being sold after having been replaced as preventive maintenance. I only run mine when I need it for calibrating an oscillator. I would expect it to be cheaper to buy another used rubidium oscillator than to repair the one I have. If it does go bad, I will look into one of the HP GPS-synchronized oscillators that are available on E-Bay. I assume if the thermal fuse is shot the oscillator won't draw any oven current? I did find a page that shows how to disassemble the 10811. It doesn't look all that inviting. Seems the author of that page had most of his problems dealing with the sticky tape they use internally. He had by the way also reported a drifting problem. That's why he took it apart. But he did say he couldn't find anything wrong with the unit either. The oven won't draw current but the oscillator will. An Ohm meter check between the oven power lead and ground should be relatively low, maybe a few hundred Ohms? You DO NOT want to disassemble the oven! All you need to do is remove the end plate. As I recall, there is a flexible cable near the card-edge connector, that hides the thermal fuse. The original thermal fuse looked like a tiny electrolytic capacitor, and plugged into tiny pin-sockets on a circuit board. The new version looks more like a ceramic quarter or half watt resistor. If you are interested, I wrote up my experience and E-Mailed it to ARRL's Hints and Kinks. It was published on Page 68 of the November, 2002, issue of QST. Please do not take this as a condemnation of the 10811 oscillator. I am very impressed with how stable it has been over a long period of time. 73, Fred, K4DII |
#7
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Fred McKenzie" wrote in message . ... Please do not take this as a condemnation of the 10811 oscillator. I am very impressed with how stable it has been over a long period of time. Thanks again for the info. -- Leland C. Scott KC8LDO Saw this on a Tee-shirt: "I am a bomb technician if you see me running try to keep up " |
#8
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]() "Fred McKenzie" wrote in message . ... Please do not take this as a condemnation of the 10811 oscillator. I am very impressed with how stable it has been over a long period of time. Thanks again for the info. -- Leland C. Scott KC8LDO Saw this on a Tee-shirt: "I am a bomb technician if you see me running try to keep up " |
#9
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Leland C. Scott" wrote in message
... Thanks again for the info. Exactly the same thing happened to me. It's fortunate I found a service manual for my frequency counter on eBay or I might never have diagnosed the problem. The manual states that the normal operating temperature for the oscillator is 80-84C. I bought new thermal fuses from Digi-Key. Investigating the properties of these devices I found that the exact temperature at which they open isn't a simple thing to determine. To be safe but avoid the fuse opening again under normal conditions, I selected a Panasonic "N124" type rated at 130C. The Digi-Key catalog number is P10922-ND. This turned out to be a bit larger than the original part. I suggest you try the smaller "F130" part, catalog number P10913-ND. Just to be safe, of course, verify these part numbers before ordering. Taking apart the oscillator is a bit nerve-wracking if you don't know what to expect, but the fuse replacement isn't at all hard to do. Have fun. -Henry |
#10
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Leland C. Scott" wrote in message
... Thanks again for the info. Exactly the same thing happened to me. It's fortunate I found a service manual for my frequency counter on eBay or I might never have diagnosed the problem. The manual states that the normal operating temperature for the oscillator is 80-84C. I bought new thermal fuses from Digi-Key. Investigating the properties of these devices I found that the exact temperature at which they open isn't a simple thing to determine. To be safe but avoid the fuse opening again under normal conditions, I selected a Panasonic "N124" type rated at 130C. The Digi-Key catalog number is P10922-ND. This turned out to be a bit larger than the original part. I suggest you try the smaller "F130" part, catalog number P10913-ND. Just to be safe, of course, verify these part numbers before ordering. Taking apart the oscillator is a bit nerve-wracking if you don't know what to expect, but the fuse replacement isn't at all hard to do. Have fun. -Henry |
Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Sources for Replacement diode for Struthers Electronics TS-1285/URM-120 h-f pickup | Equipment | |||
Sources for Replacement diode for Struthers Electronics TS-1285/URM-120 h-f pickup | Equipment | |||
RS232 "relay board" sources? | Digital | |||
RS232 "relay board" sources? | Digital | |||
651S-1 manual sources? | Boatanchors |