Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Old August 11th 04, 06:09 AM
Steve
 
Posts: n/a
Default RF Systems Mini-Windom

I've heard good things about this antenna and recently acquired one.
The performance of this antenna is terrible. In fact, it's so bad that
for the past few days I've been scratching my head, wondering what I
could possibly be doing wrong. It's a very simple setup...so simple
that I can't think of anything I *could* be doing wrong. Just hang it
and attach it to your receiver and you should be good to go. Yet the
reception I get with this antenna is vastly inferior to what I get
with my whip alone.

Is there something not mentioned in the instructions that I should
know? Please tell me I'm doing something wrong...I don't see how this
antenna could perform so badly and yet get such good reviews.

Steve (really hoping that the fault is *his*, not the antenna's)
  #2   Report Post  
Old August 11th 04, 10:12 AM
MRe
 
Posts: n/a
Default


"Steve" schreef in bericht
om...
I've heard good things about this antenna and recently acquired one.
The performance of this antenna is terrible. In fact, it's so bad that
for the past few days I've been scratching my head, wondering what I
could possibly be doing wrong. It's a very simple setup...so simple
that I can't think of anything I *could* be doing wrong. Just hang it


where did you hang it?

and attach it to your receiver


Which reciever? How attached?

and you should be good to go. Yet the
reception I get with this antenna is vastly inferior to what I get
with my whip alone.

Is there something not mentioned in the instructions that I should
know? Please tell me I'm doing something wrong...I don't see how this
antenna could perform so badly and yet get such good reviews.


It is not possible to give an answer on this question.
Please give (much) more details of your setup.

MRe


  #3   Report Post  
Old August 11th 04, 04:30 PM
Steve
 
Posts: n/a
Default

"MRe" wrote in message et.nl...
"Steve" schreef in bericht
om...
I've heard good things about this antenna and recently acquired one.
The performance of this antenna is terrible. In fact, it's so bad that
for the past few days I've been scratching my head, wondering what I
could possibly be doing wrong. It's a very simple setup...so simple
that I can't think of anything I *could* be doing wrong. Just hang it


where did you hang it?

and attach it to your receiver


Which reciever? How attached?

and you should be good to go. Yet the
reception I get with this antenna is vastly inferior to what I get
with my whip alone.

Is there something not mentioned in the instructions that I should
know? Please tell me I'm doing something wrong...I don't see how this
antenna could perform so badly and yet get such good reviews.


It is not possible to give an answer on this question.
Please give (much) more details of your setup.

MRe


I hung the antenna outside, using the provided nylon cords, on my
balcony. It's attached to the external antenna jack of a portable
receiver (Sony ICF-SW77). I had to use an adaptor so that it would fit
the small antenna jack on my Sony, but it's the same adaptor I've used
with other antennas, which seem to work okay.

Steve
  #4   Report Post  
Old August 11th 04, 04:59 PM
dxAce
 
Posts: n/a
Default



Steve wrote:

"MRe" wrote in message et.nl...
"Steve" schreef in bericht
om...
I've heard good things about this antenna and recently acquired one.
The performance of this antenna is terrible. In fact, it's so bad that
for the past few days I've been scratching my head, wondering what I
could possibly be doing wrong. It's a very simple setup...so simple
that I can't think of anything I *could* be doing wrong. Just hang it


where did you hang it?

and attach it to your receiver


Which reciever? How attached?

and you should be good to go. Yet the
reception I get with this antenna is vastly inferior to what I get
with my whip alone.

Is there something not mentioned in the instructions that I should
know? Please tell me I'm doing something wrong...I don't see how this
antenna could perform so badly and yet get such good reviews.


It is not possible to give an answer on this question.
Please give (much) more details of your setup.

MRe


I hung the antenna outside, using the provided nylon cords, on my
balcony. It's attached to the external antenna jack of a portable
receiver (Sony ICF-SW77). I had to use an adaptor so that it would fit
the small antenna jack on my Sony, but it's the same adaptor I've used
with other antennas, which seem to work okay.


Although it is only 16' long that antenna should give as good or better results than the whip on SW.

I just looked at a pic of the jacks on the SW77 and I notice that it says 'AM ext ant'... could it be that that jack
is only for attaching an external AM antenna rather than one for SW?

I have no experience with that receiver at all but I guess I have to ask that question. What does the manual say about
that jack, and about hooking up an external SW antenna?

dxAce



Steve


  #5   Report Post  
Old August 11th 04, 05:00 PM
Steve
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Oh, I should add that I was very careful about following the
instructions provided with the antenna for hanging it. It's not hung
against a wall, for example, and is as far out on my balcony as I
could possibly put it. The coax feedline drops straight down from the
antenna, comes through my window and plugs into the antenna jack on
the Sony SW77. I don't think that this antenna is supposed to require
a ground, so I'm really puzzled about what I might be doing wrong.

Steve


  #6   Report Post  
Old August 11th 04, 08:28 PM
Steve
 
Posts: n/a
Default

dxAce wrote in message ...
Steve wrote:

"MRe" wrote in message et.nl...
"Steve" schreef in bericht
om...
I've heard good things about this antenna and recently acquired one.
The performance of this antenna is terrible. In fact, it's so bad that
for the past few days I've been scratching my head, wondering what I
could possibly be doing wrong. It's a very simple setup...so simple
that I can't think of anything I *could* be doing wrong. Just hang it

where did you hang it?

and attach it to your receiver

Which reciever? How attached?

and you should be good to go. Yet the
reception I get with this antenna is vastly inferior to what I get
with my whip alone.

Is there something not mentioned in the instructions that I should
know? Please tell me I'm doing something wrong...I don't see how this
antenna could perform so badly and yet get such good reviews.


It is not possible to give an answer on this question.
Please give (much) more details of your setup.

MRe


I hung the antenna outside, using the provided nylon cords, on my
balcony. It's attached to the external antenna jack of a portable
receiver (Sony ICF-SW77). I had to use an adaptor so that it would fit
the small antenna jack on my Sony, but it's the same adaptor I've used
with other antennas, which seem to work okay.


Although it is only 16' long that antenna should give as good or better results than the whip on SW.

I just looked at a pic of the jacks on the SW77 and I notice that it says 'AM ext ant'... could it be that that jack
is only for attaching an external AM antenna rather than one for SW?

I have no experience with that receiver at all but I guess I have to ask that question. What does the manual say about
that jack, and about hooking up an external SW antenna?

dxAce


A perfectly reasonable question, but the manual is clear that the
antenna you might be attaching to the jack is a SW antenna. They
explicitly say it's for LW/MW/SW reception.

Steve
  #7   Report Post  
Old August 11th 04, 08:32 PM
dxAce
 
Posts: n/a
Default



Steve wrote:

dxAce wrote in message ...
Steve wrote:

"MRe" wrote in message et.nl...
"Steve" schreef in bericht
om...
I've heard good things about this antenna and recently acquired one.
The performance of this antenna is terrible. In fact, it's so bad that
for the past few days I've been scratching my head, wondering what I
could possibly be doing wrong. It's a very simple setup...so simple
that I can't think of anything I *could* be doing wrong. Just hang it

where did you hang it?

and attach it to your receiver

Which reciever? How attached?

and you should be good to go. Yet the
reception I get with this antenna is vastly inferior to what I get
with my whip alone.

Is there something not mentioned in the instructions that I should
know? Please tell me I'm doing something wrong...I don't see how this
antenna could perform so badly and yet get such good reviews.


It is not possible to give an answer on this question.
Please give (much) more details of your setup.

MRe

I hung the antenna outside, using the provided nylon cords, on my
balcony. It's attached to the external antenna jack of a portable
receiver (Sony ICF-SW77). I had to use an adaptor so that it would fit
the small antenna jack on my Sony, but it's the same adaptor I've used
with other antennas, which seem to work okay.


Although it is only 16' long that antenna should give as good or better results than the whip on SW.

I just looked at a pic of the jacks on the SW77 and I notice that it says 'AM ext ant'... could it be that that jack
is only for attaching an external AM antenna rather than one for SW?

I have no experience with that receiver at all but I guess I have to ask that question. What does the manual say about
that jack, and about hooking up an external SW antenna?

dxAce


A perfectly reasonable question, but the manual is clear that the
antenna you might be attaching to the jack is a SW antenna. They
explicitly say it's for LW/MW/SW reception.


OK, wasn't sure from the description on the jack itself. Might want to re-check your connections again if you've not yet
done so.

As I said earlier, you ought to get at least comparable performance to your whip or better from that antenna.

Let us know if you get it sorted out.

dxAce


  #9   Report Post  
Old August 12th 04, 01:26 AM
Steve
 
Posts: n/a
Default

dxAce wrote in message ...
Steve wrote:

dxAce wrote in message ...
Steve wrote:

"MRe" wrote in message et.nl...
"Steve" schreef in bericht
om...
I've heard good things about this antenna and recently acquired one.
The performance of this antenna is terrible. In fact, it's so bad that
for the past few days I've been scratching my head, wondering what I
could possibly be doing wrong. It's a very simple setup...so simple
that I can't think of anything I *could* be doing wrong. Just hang it

where did you hang it?

and attach it to your receiver

Which reciever? How attached?

and you should be good to go. Yet the
reception I get with this antenna is vastly inferior to what I get
with my whip alone.

Is there something not mentioned in the instructions that I should
know? Please tell me I'm doing something wrong...I don't see how this
antenna could perform so badly and yet get such good reviews.


It is not possible to give an answer on this question.
Please give (much) more details of your setup.

MRe

I hung the antenna outside, using the provided nylon cords, on my
balcony. It's attached to the external antenna jack of a portable
receiver (Sony ICF-SW77). I had to use an adaptor so that it would fit
the small antenna jack on my Sony, but it's the same adaptor I've used
with other antennas, which seem to work okay.

Although it is only 16' long that antenna should give as good or better results than the whip on SW.

I just looked at a pic of the jacks on the SW77 and I notice that it says 'AM ext ant'... could it be that that jack
is only for attaching an external AM antenna rather than one for SW?

I have no experience with that receiver at all but I guess I have to ask that question. What does the manual say about
that jack, and about hooking up an external SW antenna?

dxAce


A perfectly reasonable question, but the manual is clear that the
antenna you might be attaching to the jack is a SW antenna. They
explicitly say it's for LW/MW/SW reception.


OK, wasn't sure from the description on the jack itself. Might want to re-check your connections again if you've not yet
done so.

As I said earlier, you ought to get at least comparable performance to your whip or better from that antenna.

Let us know if you get it sorted out.

dxAce



Thanks. I will. The only thing that makes me doubt that there's a
problem with the jack is the fact that this same radio (with the same
jack) works very well with other antennas that I occasionally use.
I've heard such good reviews of this 'low noise' antenna that I sure
hope I can figure out what's wrong.
  #10   Report Post  
Old August 12th 04, 08:53 AM
RHF
 
Posts: n/a
Default

= = = (Steve) wrote in message
= = = . com...
"MRe" wrote in message et.nl...
"Steve" schreef in bericht
om...
I've heard good things about this antenna and recently acquired one.
The performance of this antenna is terrible. In fact, it's so bad that
for the past few days I've been scratching my head, wondering what I
could possibly be doing wrong. It's a very simple setup...so simple
that I can't think of anything I *could* be doing wrong. Just hang it


where did you hang it?

and attach it to your receiver


Which reciever? How attached?

and you should be good to go. Yet the
reception I get with this antenna is vastly inferior to what I get
with my whip alone.

Is there something not mentioned in the instructions that I should
know? Please tell me I'm doing something wrong...I don't see how this
antenna could perform so badly and yet get such good reviews.


It is not possible to give an answer on this question.
Please give (much) more details of your setup.

MRe


I hung the antenna outside, using the provided nylon cords, on my
balcony. It's attached to the external antenna jack of a portable
receiver (Sony ICF-SW77). I had to use an adaptor so that it would fit
the small antenna jack on my Sony, but it's the same adaptor I've used
with other antennas, which seem to work okay.

Steve



STEVE,

Take the Mini-Windon Antenna and your Sony ICF-SW77
to the Park. Find a Picnic Table between two trees.
String up the Antenna between the two trees. Connect
the Antenna to the Radio. Preform a AM/SW Reception
Test of the Antenna and Radio in an 'open environment'.
If everything "Tests OK" then it is the 'location and
positioning' of the Mini-Windom Antenna ON YOUR BALCONY
that is the problem.

iane ~ RHF

..
Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
FCC: Broadband Power Line Systems Paul Policy 0 January 10th 05 06:41 PM
Windom vs G5RV : 1-0 Thierry Antenna 0 October 4th 04 09:58 PM
stuff for all hams [email protected] General 0 December 19th 03 08:31 PM
OLD motorola trunking information jack smith Scanner 1 December 12th 03 10:48 AM
RF amps: tuned load in Class A? Don Pearce Homebrew 141 September 15th 03 06:02 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:41 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2025 RadioBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about Radio"

 

Copyright © 2017